Film should have been so much better than this. The dramatic material was there, James Mangold just couldn't deliver it.
Robert Patrick was a standout. He was amazing in the scene where he chastizes his son about the tractor. Mangold robs him though by cutting away for reaction shots. Mangold undercuts the emotions of the scene. The scene could've been powerful.
And then why would Mangold choose to use, in two pivotal scenes, songs by Elvis and Dylan??? That is mind-boggling.
Then there's the freeze frame to end the film at such a "nothing" moment. Mangold couldn't find anything stronger than that to freeze upon?
Reese Witherspoon was the heart of the film. Her performance was pitch perfect.
Joaquin Phoenix was amazing. Strong acting performances all around.
No comments:
Post a Comment